Blind Melon Articles: a fan-built Blind Melon archive

The "Commodore Ballroom" Recording Is MuchMusic

Why "Live in Vancouver, Commodore Ballroom 1995" is the MuchMusic Intimate & Interactive show, Toronto, September 12, 1995

One of the most widely shared Blind Melon live recordings goes by many names: "Live in Vancouver," "Commodore Ballroom 1995," "Commodore Ballroom 9/12/95," even "1995-03-10: Commodore Ballroom." Under every name it is the same 16 songs in the same order, and they were not recorded in Vancouver.

They are Blind Melon's performance for MuchMusic's "Intimate & Interactive," taped at the CHUM-City Building on Queen Street West in Toronto on September 12, 1995.

Nobody has to take that on faith. Below are seven separate checks, most of which anyone can repeat in a few minutes. If you came here from a "Commodore" upload, start with number 1.

1. Capitol dates the MuchMusic set to September 12, 1995

Capitol's 2005 DVD "Live at the Metro: September 27, 1995" ends with three bonus tracks under the heading "Bonus Tracks recorded live on MuchMusic September 12, 1995": "Toes Across the Floor," "Change" and "Soup."

All three songs are on every "Commodore" copy. Put the official DVD versions next to the same three songs on any "Commodore" upload and listen for the details that only one performance can share: the count-ins, the vocal slips, the talk between songs.

The band's own 1995 tour calendar agrees on the date: September 12 is listed as "Toronto, Canada, Much Music."

2. The band was in Toronto that day

The archive.org copy is titled "Blind Melon Live at Commodore Ballroom on 1995-09-12," and its notes read "9/12/95 Commodore Ballroom Vancouver, BC SBD."

On September 12, 1995 Blind Melon was in Toronto taping for MuchMusic, more than 3,300 km (2,000 miles) from Vancouver. The date on that label is the MuchMusic date with the wrong venue attached.

The band did play the Commodore Ballroom on that tour, three weeks later, on October 3, 1995, between the Moore Theatre in Seattle (October 2) and La Luna in Portland (October 4).

3. The oldest bootleg admits it

The earliest pressing found is "A Long Strange Trip to Canada," an unofficial CD from Canada on the Roots label, dated 1995. Its Discogs entry says it was "Recorded live in Toronto, on 9/12/95 @ The Chum City Building" and that the "Rear insert incorrectly lists the recording in Vancouver on 10/3/1995."

That CD runs 20 tracks: the 16 MuchMusic songs, then "Galaxie" and "Walk" credited to a BBC session, then "Change" and "No Rain" from Hilversum, Holland, in 1993.

The same 20 tracks in the same order turn up again on "Climbing the Clouds," a 1996 Czech bootleg (Oxygen OXY 033), which copied the insert's "Commodore Ballroom, Vancouver, October 3, 1995" credit, and on fan uploads titled both "MuchMusic Intimate & Interactive 9.12.95" and "1995-03-10: Commodore Ballroom." One set of tapes, two stories about where it came from, and the earliest source says which one is wrong.

4. Same songs, same order, same lengths

The table below lines up four copies. The two fan uploads, one labeled MuchMusic and one labeled Commodore, have the same length for every one of the 16 songs, to the second.

The streaming album "The Commodore 1995 (Live)" matches 9 of the 16 track lengths exactly. The rest differ by a few seconds to half a minute, the kind of difference you get when the same tape is split at slightly different points between songs. Some of its track names still carry the file names they were ripped from, such as "15 Galaxie.Flac" and "16 Car Seat.Flac."

Track lengths are as listed on Last.fm. The archive.org "9/12/95" copy lists file sizes rather than lengths, but its 16 tracks run in exactly this order.

Side by side: three labels, one set

#SongLabeled "MuchMusic Intimate & Interactive 9.12.95"Labeled "1995-03-10: Commodore Ballroom"Streaming album "The Commodore 1995 (Live)"
12x44:004:004:25
2Toes Across the Floor3:053:053:05
3Tones of Home4:584:584:58
4Wilt2:482:482:48
5Vernie3:213:213:46
6No Rain3:373:374:07
7Walk2:372:372:44
8Lemonade2:572:572:57
9Time4:404:404:40
10St. Andrew's Fall3:593:593:59
11Skinned2:312:312:31
12Change3:423:423:33
13Soup3:203:203:22
14The Duke3:423:423:42
15Galaxie3:053:052:43
16Car Seat2:582:582:58

5. The odd dates are the same dates, misread

Written day-first, as most of the world writes dates, "9.12.95" becomes 9 December 1995. That is the "release date" these files carry on Last.fm and in streaming catalogs, seven weeks after Shannon Hoon died.

"10/3/95," the date on the Canadian CD's insert, read the same way becomes 10 March 1995. That is how one copy ended up titled "1995-03-10: Commodore Ballroom."

So every date attached to this recording traces back to two originals: September 12, 1995 (the real date) and October 3, 1995 (the insert's mistake).

6. It can't be the 1993 Commodore shows either

Blind Melon also played the Commodore on December 20 and 21, 1993, on the tour for their first album.

11 of the 16 songs on the "Commodore" recording are from Soup, which came out in August 1995, and "Soup" itself later appeared on Nico. A December 1993 club show would not be built around a record still 20 months away.

7. It's the length of a TV taping, not a headline show

The music on the "Commodore" copies runs about 56 minutes and ends quietly with "Car Seat." The Intimate & Interactive broadcast ran about 68 minutes including interviews.

Two weeks later, on September 27, 1995, Blind Melon's headline show at the Metro in Chicago, released officially by Capitol, ran 19 songs and about 76 minutes, including "Soak the Sun," "Dumptruck," "I Wonder," "Paper Scratcher" and "After Hours." None of those are on the "Commodore" copies.

The mix-up is part of the history

None of this is meant to scold anyone. A Canadian bootlegger put the wrong venue on an insert in 1995, and file sharing did the rest: every trade, upload and re-upload copied the label along with the music, and each new copy made the wrong name look more established. Thirty years on, it is probably the most widely mislabeled Blind Melon recording there is.

The labels can't be taken back, and the archive keeps a record of them, because how a recording traveled is part of its story too. What can change is what listeners know. If you love this recording, you are hearing a real and very good Blind Melon performance. It just happened in a Toronto TV studio, not a Vancouver ballroom.

Where the mislabel shows up

The Live Music Archive at archive.org, item "bm1995-09-12.sbd," uploaded in 2009 as "Commodore Ballroom, Vancouver, 9/12/95, SBD."

The streaming album "The Commodore 1995 (Live)" on Apple Music and other services, whose tracks also appear as auto-generated "Provided to YouTube" videos on Blind Melon's YouTube artist channel.

Last.fm, as "The Commodore 1995 (Live)" and "1995-03-10: Commodore Ballroom, Vancouver, BC, Canada."

Discogs, as "Climbing the Clouds" (1996), credited to the Commodore, and "A Long Strange Trip to Canada" (1995), whose Discogs notes already flag the insert as wrong.

This site does not link to broadcast footage or broadcast audio, so these are named rather than linked.

What is still unknown

No recording of the real Commodore shows (December 20 and 21, 1993, or October 3, 1995) has turned up. If you have one, please get in touch through the Contact page.

A screen-printed gig poster for Blind Melon at the Commodore, by Ryan G. Miller and dated "9/12," is listed on Expresso Beans with the year 1995. On September 12, 1995 the band was in Toronto. The Commodore plus 9/12 pairing is exactly the archive.org label, so the poster most likely took its date from the mislabeled recording rather than from a real show.

Blind Melon Articles

Tour Dates Archive

Tap the image to zoom in or out
Open in a new tab ↗
BMA

Support Blind Melon first

This archive is a fan-built companion. Please buy and stream the band's music, see them live when they tour, and visit their official store.

▲▼